Students expressed concerns with proposed freshmen-only housing last night at the third of the continuing series of "Fireside Chats" last night in Collis Commonground.
Dean of the College James Larimore began the evening suggesting that the conversation for the night should center around residential life and the issue of housing segregated by class year quickly arose.
Some seniors said that they were often distracted by the freshmen on their hall and proposed that upperclass students have a choice on whether they wish to live with freshmen or not.
Others disagreed, saying that when they were freshmen they appreciated being able to go to upperclass students for advice.
One person mentioned that living off-campus also affected interaction with new students, saying that students often give up the beneficial opportunity to meet new students when do not live in College residence halls.
Students also expressed many different views on the role of Undergraduate Advisors.
Some expressed the concern that sophomore UGAs did not have the knowledge to accurately advise first-year students, though others responded that quality was more dependent on the individual.
Many agreed that if UGAs were offered better compensation the College would find more individuals willing to take on the job, and some suggested that offering more pay or free room and board would increase the number of applicants for the position.
One graduate commented that senior-only housing may force people away from the community and that people should feel responsible for the quality of their community.
Opinions on the proposed cluster system varied as well. Some people said that they were very comfortable with moving each year and meeting new people, while others complained that it was a hassle.
One student mentioned that a goal of the five principles was continuity and choice, and that the current discussion was focusing mostly on continuity.
College President James Wright said that providing the opportunity to meet different students is very important and that the College should enlarge opportunities for first-year students.
Trustee David Shipler '64, who also attended the event, added that the test of any institution is how self-correcting it is and that he felt Dartmouth is very willing to change.
Several students stayed afterwards to further discuss issues with Larimore.
Dean of the College James Larimore will host another fireside chat next Monday at the Commonground.
